Buying Selling Shares

Claim of minority to buy majority Shares in a proceeding under section 397/398 of Companies Act – Indian Company Law

Settling or putting an end to the disputes among shareholders by the Company Law Board under section 397/398 of the Companies Act, 1956 is a complicated job. When where exist serious difference of opinion among the minority and majority shareholders in a Private Limited Company, it would really be difficult for the Company Law Board to put an end to the matters complained of or to regularize the affairs of the Company. It is not easy to apply the settled legal principles or to give effect to the literal meaning of section 397/298 of the Companies Act, 1956 and the connected provisions. While a petition alleging Oppression and Mismanagement under section 397/398 of the Companies Act, 1956 is pending, the controlling shareholders in the Company continue to do certain acts and it is not easy for the Company Law Board to pass a blanket order on the controlling shareholders that they should not transact any business in the Company while the Petition is pending. Technically, the majority shareholders may continue to file various forms with the Registrar of Companies (ROC) as required, may get the accounts audited and can very well contend that the Company is being managed in accordance with the provisions of the Companies Act, 1956.  But, the minority shareholders may apprehend or may know as to how the Company is being mismanaged.  These are all various complications in dealing with a Petition under section 397/398 of the Companies Act, 1956.

There tend to be problems in all closely held companies whether it is Private or the Public Limited Company. In most of the cases of oppression and mismanagement, either there can be out of court settlement or settlement before the Board. Even in the absence of any settlement, the Company Law Board, after following the procedure for ascertaining the value of shares, can ask a group to buy another group on the ground that either there exist a dead lock or it can justify that the order of buying one group by another is the only solution to put an end to the matters complained of.  While it is true that there are cases where the minority in the Company may unreasonably struggle despite the legal protection, the minority group may also force the majority to come to terms through litigation and especially by filing a Petition under section 397/398 of the Companies Act, 1956 asking for various relief including investigation into the affairs of the Company at times.  The certain basic concepts of law pertaining to oppression and mismanagement under the Companies Act, 1956 have changed in the recent past; it has only benefited the minority. For example, earlier a proceeding under section 397/398 of the Companies Act, 1956 is seen as an extraordinary remedy and the Petitioners should establish that the alleged acts of oppression and mismanagement are really “harsh and burdensome”. Now, no petition under section 397/398 of the Companies Act, 1956 is getting dismissed on technical grounds and I have seen a judgment that where the Court has said that the Company Law Board can pass orders in a Petition under section 397/398 of the Companies Act, 1956 even if the oppression and mismanagement has not proved in strict senso.

When it comes to the claim of minority shareholders to buy-out majority, it is normally not accepted unless the majority favours the decision by its omissions and commissions during the proceeding before the Company Law Board. It is often seen where the majority is asked to buy minority shares at the agreed price or the price determined by the Board. This is an interesting issue to discuss as to whether the minority can claim that they be allowed to buy majority with the sanction of the Company Law Board. In my personal opinion, at times, based on the typical facts and circumstances of the case and based on the threat to the rights of the minority shareholders, the Company Law Board can ask the minority to buy-out majority if the majority is not willing to buy the minority. There can be cases where the majority may say that they do not have money to buy the Shares Of minority and they may say that they have no objection to allow the minority shareholders to sell their shares to any outsider. But, the fact remains that no outsider will come and agree to buy the shares of the minority in a closely held Private Company.

The issue of claim of minority to buy majority and the authority of the Company Law Board to ask the majority to sell their shares to the majority would always remain complicated and it all depends upon the facts and circumstances of each and every case and there can not be any hard and fast rule.

Elaborately dealing with the issue in the light of similar provisions in the company legislations of other countries, and dealing with the essentials for maintaining a petition under section 397/398 of Companies Act, 1956, the Hon’ble High Court of Madras in K.R.S.Narayana Iyengar Vs. T.A.Mani reported in 1960 AIR (MAD) was pleased to discuss and opine as follows:

“(15) There are as yet few English decisions on this S. 210. The Scottish and South African cases referred to below are the principal sources of elucidation. The equivalent south African section is 111 of the South African COMPANIES ACT. In Marshall v. Marshall (Poty) Ltd. , (1954) 3 SA 571 at p. 580 an order was made because one of three directors and shareholders in a private company had justifiably lost confidence in one of the others, who had behaved with obvious impropriety, but whose removal was blocked by the second. In Taylore v. Welkon Theatres Ltd. , (1954) 3 SA 339, it was held similarly, as in the Scottish case of Elder v. Elder and Watson Ltd. , 1952 SC 49 that the section was designed to put an end to a continuing state of affairs and the oppression must be in the affairs of the company and not the independent conduct of some other company or individual and not to give monetary compensation for a wrong no longer continuing and the society can be ordered to purchase the minority shares at a fair value. In Irvin and Johnson, Ltd. v. Oelofse Fisheries Ltd., (1954) 1 SA 231 it was held that an order could only be made if it could effectively enable the company to survive. In 1952 SC 49 (Ibid), Lord Cooper laid down a useful working rule about the meaning of oppression in this context, saying that the essence of the matter seems to be that the conduct complained of should at the lowest involve a visible departure from the standards of fair dealing, and a violation of the conditions of fair play on which every shareholder who entrusts his money to a company is entitled to rely. More succinctly it has been stated that the complaining shareholder must be under a burden which is unjust or harsh or tyrannical. A persistent and persisting course of unjust conduct must be shown. In the only United Kingdom case in which this section has been successfully invoked, Mayer v. Scottish Textile and Manufacturing Co. , 1954 SC 381, it was held that if the allegations on which the petition was filed could be sustained, the society would be ordered to purchase the minority’s shares at a fair value. (15-A) Bearing these principles in mind, if we examine the facts of this case, the only just and equitable solution which can be imposed in the context of this case is to ask the respondents to buy up the shares of the petitioners. The reliefs asked for, which would practically tantamount to ruining this company and the interests of the majority shareholders and achieve for minority shareholders what they would not have achieved either in the civil suits or by winding up, cannot be granted. But in regard to buying up, this solution need not be imposed by me, because there is a suit already pending in the Sub Court, Tiruchirapalli, for that purpose and as a matter of fact the respondents are ready and willing to pay even more than what they have stipulated for to buy up the shares of the petitioners. But so emboldened have the applicants become by their obstructive tactics of harassing the respondents that they are now claiming right to buy up the majority shareholders. In short it has become a case of not the dog wagging the tail but the tail wagging the dog.”

Note: The views expressed are my personal and I am ware of the vastness of the subject and complications in the course.

About the Author

V.DURGA RAO, Advocate, Madras High Court.

Email: vdrao_attorney@yahoo.co.in

http://indiancorporatelaws.blogspot.com/

When directors buy or sell shares in their companies, Sikonathi Mantshantsha

The First-Time Investor: The Complete Guide to Buying, Owning and Selling Shares $41.44 No Synopsis Available

Buying Property In Portugal: Insider Tips On Buying, Selling And Renting In Portugal $9.61 Buying a place in Portugal should be easy yet far too many people have fallen foul of the hidden dangers that can bring your property dreams crashing down around you. In this straightforward guide Gabrielle Collison shares her tips on how to minimise the risks and enjoy a trouble free purchase.

Selling in Tough Times: Secrets to Selling When No One Is Buying $5.99 Tough Times can be brought on by any number of factors: a down economy, Mother Nature, shifts in customers’ needs, national tragedy – the list goes on and on. These types of changes can be extremely disruptive, even paralyzing, when we’re not prepared for them. While many see no other option than to “sit tight” and “ride things out” when crisis strikes, true career professionals in selling understand that the only way to deal with adversity is to meet it head-on. That’s why a positive attitude and a proactive approach to problem-solving are two of the most essential ingredients for success in selling – and why those who embrace them not only survive but thrive, even in the most difficult of circumstances. Now, in his latest book, SELLING IN TOUGH TIMES, world-renowned selling expert Tom Hopkins puts his real-world , in-the-trenches experience to work and shares his plan to reverse the momentum of tough times – and even capitalize on them. With exercises to help you discover previously overlooked opportunities and eliminate waste, along with out-of-the-box methods for recruiting new customers and key tips on how to solidify your existing business, Hopkins gives you powerful ways to spur sales now and for years to come. Learn how to: Mine your client list to generate new leads. Keep – and reward – your current customers so that they’re loyal for life. Reduce the sales resistance that plagues tough times with tactics that overcome consumers’ fears. Woo clients from your competition with 12 new strategies specially tailored for tough times. Cycles will come and go, but the principles of great selling and those who live by them stand firm. Find out how you can achieve your maximum selling potential, whatever the business climate, in SELLING IN TOUGH TIMES today.

Selling In Tough Times: Secrets To Selling When No One Is Buying $9.99 Tough Times can be brought on by any number of factors: a down economy Mother Nature shifts in customers’ needs national tragedy–the list goes on and on. These types of changes can be extremely disruptive even paralyzing when we’re not prepared for them. While many see no other option than to "sit tight" and "ride things out" when crisis strikes true career professionals in selling understand that the only way to deal with adversity is to meet it head-on. That’s why a positive attitude and a proactive approach to problem-solving are two of the most essential ingredients for success in selling–and why those who embrace them not only to survive but thrive even in the most difficult of circumstances. Now in his latest book SELLING IN TOUGH TIMES world-renowned selling expert Tom Hopkins puts his real-world in-the-trenches experience to work and shares his plan to reverse the momentum of tough times–and even capitalize on them. With exercises to help you discover previously overlooked opportunities and eliminate waste along with out-of-the-box methods for recruiting new customers and key tips on how to solidify your existing business Hopkins gives you powerful ways to spur sales now and for years to come. Learn how to: Mine your client list to generate new leads Keep–and reward–your current customers so that they’re loyal for life. Reduce the sales resistance that plagues tough times with tactics that overcome consumers’ fears. Woo clients from your competition with 12 new strategies specially tailored for tough times. Cycles will come and go but the principles of great selling and those who live by them stand firm. Find out how you can achieve your maximum selling potential whatever the business climate in SELLING IN TOUGH TIMES today.

Shares Made Simple: A Beginners Guide to Sharemarket Success $15.99 Are you thinking of joining the thousands of Australians profiting from our stock market, but intimidated by the jargon and unsure of where to start? Let Australia’s foremost share-investing educator guide you through the simplest ways to make money from shares — and how to ensure you protect your hard-earned dollars in the process! Shares Made Simple is the essential ground-up investing guide for stock market beginners. Unlike most sharemarket guides, this book explains in simple language all the relevant stock market terms and definitions; includes practical, uncomplicated tips after each succinct section to ensure readers have grasped concepts clearly; and then provides straightforward strategies for profiting on the market — no expensive financial advisor required! Kinsky covers everything you’ll need to get started and get ahead: buying and selling shares, building a portfolio, managing risk, dealing with dividends and how to pick the best stocks.

Buying And Selling A Small Bus(Pack of 1) $20.99 A great help for buying, selling or expanding small businesses.

Buying and Selling a Home For Canadians For Dummies $14.99 Buying and selling a home are the biggest financial transactions most people will ever tackle. Well, help has arrived. This revised edition of Buying and Selling a Home For Canadians For Dummies prepares you to get what you need and want when buying a new home or selling the one you’re in. Everything from arranging your finances and hiring an agent, to inspecting prospective homes and assessing home values, to making or fielding offers is presented in a clear and humorous way to help you get the most out of the process.

Branded : The Buying and Selling of Teenagers $15.23 No Synopsis Available

Buying The Land Selling The Land $10.79 New Zealand History